Friday, December 16, 2011

The Great War and the Illustrated Press

This call for papers is taken wholesale from the excellent ECREA mailing list. The conference seems to be a rare opportunity to widen the field of Magazine Studies: " the illustrated magazines conveyed images of the war that were shared by European societies both during and after the conflict. This symposium aims at seizing the opportunity of this anniversary to shed new lights on the European and American illustrated press, including its function and its influence on the cultural representations of the nations before, during and after the war."

The Great War and the Illustrated Press, June 5th, 6th and 7th 2013

We are pleased to announce an extended Call for Paper for the symposium organized by the OPIIM, LabSIC, MSH-Paris Nord, and Université de Paris-XIII
The year 2014 will commemorate the anniversary of the beginning of the Great War. This will be an opportunity to review our most recent knowledge about this event. One could assume, considering the amount of books published on the matter, that everything has already been said during the last twenty years concerning the cultural history of the Great War, leaving but few uncharted areas. However, as far as the iconography is concerned, there are only a few studies that have contributed to such historiographic developments, if we except those published by Laurent Véray on animated images, from news bulletins (1993) to fiction movies (2011). In the case of illustrated press, this fact is particularly striking. Although this field has benefited from more recent approaches (Beurier, 2007), it still lacks a broader, European point of view (Tomassini, 2007). It also lead to very few comparative works as it has been the case for the 1870 War (Martin, 2006). Yet, the illustrated magazines conveyed images of the war that were shared by European societies both during and after the conflict. This symposium aims at seizing the opportunity of this anniversary to shed new lights on the European and American illustrated press, including its function and its influence on the cultural representations of the nations before, during and after the war.

A research following various lines:     

1. Before the war started, we need to look at the visual culture of the pre-war societies. What about the “in-war images”? Is the public used to violence, to what extent and under which visual format? What are the kinds of information and images that make you sell more out of one event? To what extent the coverage of preceding wars (1870-1871, Balkans, colonial events) did introduce certain visual habits that reappeared between 1914 and 1918? Besides, magazines enable us to investigate the mental preparation to war. In the case of France, unlike what was long thought, there was no will for revenge. However, to what extent the veneration of the army that dominated illustrated press in the years 1910 can be understood as a psychological preparation? Was it also the case in other European countries?

2. Concerning the time span of the Great War, an account is needed on the articles and documents written by the illustrated press on the event. What are the most favourite themes in the various European countries? How do the words and images convey the violence of combats or occupation? How can they be analyzed in terms of gender? How the colonial soldiers are viewed? How important is the part played by the aesthetics of war in photography? What lines can be drawn in terms of chronology? It is also important to understand the links between the illustrated press and the war in the context of a history of the medium. To what extent did the Great War stimulate editorial changes, modifying the magazine’s conception, reversing the common hierarchy between photography and paintings, or creating new practices in journalism (as it has been the case in France)?

3. A third period ought to ponder upon the legacy of the war. What is the impact of the latter in the illustrated press of the years 1920, both in Europe and the United States? From a national point of view, what are the contents and representation of the Great War in the magazines that were issued afterwards? Did the photography play an important part in the reintegration of soldiers? What representation of the conflict or Nation does it convey? Is there a possibility left to forget about the war, or deny it; or on the contrary, is violence voluntarily shown? Here, the circulation of images is worth a specific study: did the numerous journalistic (Témoignage, 1931) or editorial (Krieg dem Kriege, 1924) publications have an influence on after war illustrated magazines? How do images circulate? From and up to where? Through which pattern or changes? In between which countries? Similarly, up to what point the iconographic legacy of the Great War is used without change in the following conflicts (Rif War, Civil War in Russia)? How far can it be traced as we close in on World War Two?
Eventually, from the point of view of media history, there subsists an uncharted area concerning the legacy of the Great War in terms of press professional practices. More precisely, it can be wondered why photojournalism had disappeared in France until the end of the 1920s and the issue of the Vu magazine in 1928 by Lucien Vogel. Similar observations can be made in other countries. What happened in the meantime? What became of the magazines that relied on pictures in the war time? How did they evolve to meet their readers’ needs? Did they learn from their war experience in terms of professional and editorial practices? How did famous post war photographers like André Kertesz use their experience of the Great War in their work? Last but not least, it can be asked whether there exists a possible link between information such as delivered by the Great War magazines and journalism today (such as the importance of amateur photographers, or pictures bringing back images of the Great War)?

Contributions on Eastern Europe and/or North America will be particularly welcome.

Travel and hotel costs of invited presenters will be refunded.

The symposium will take place in June, 5th, 6th, 7th 2013 in the MSH-Paris Nord. The articles selected by the scientific committee will be published in 2014.

The projects (250 words) must be sent to before February 25th, 2012.

Scientific committee : Pr. Jean Jacques Becker (Paris X), Pr. Christian Delporte (Saint-Quentin-en-Yvelines), Pr. Bertrand Legendre (Paris XIII), Pr. Jean-Claude Lescure (Cergy Pontoise), Pr. Hans-Jürgen Lüsebrink (Sarrebruck), Pr. Marie-Eve Therenty (Montpellier), Pr. Luigi Tomassini (Bologna).

ECREA-Mailing list
This mailing list is a free service from ECREA.
To unsubscribe, please visit
ECREA - European Communication Research and Education Association
Postal address:
Université Libre de Bruxelles
c/o Dept. of Information and Communication Sciences
CP123, avenue F.D. Roosevelt 50, b-1050 Bruxelles, Belgium

Monday, December 05, 2011

The toybox as a toolbox

When I was much younger I had a wooden chest full of Meccano, the metal version with proper nuts and bolts; when my son was a bit younger he had a big box full of Lego, standard bricks and special kits all mixed up together.

In both cases we could build things, make structures that were stable or unstable, see how to fit pieces together to achieve a particular end – and learn about the physical world through play. The toybox became a toolbox without us even realising.

I got the same feeling watching our postgraduate Magazine students put together podcasts under the watchful eye of Broadcast tutor Emma Gilliam. The toybox was full of microphones, buttons, knobs, faders, flashing lights – all the paraphernalia of a radio studio control board. Under Emma’s practised eye the students built soundscapes that began to fit together into a structured whole; they adjusted bits that didn’t work and reinforced bits that did. Just like playing with Meccano and Lego, the words and voices and technology merged into a tremendous learning experience.

I loved being in the studio, listening and watching as Emma brought everything together. It was a great example of what we strive to do in the Cardiff postgraduate journalism courses – break down silos, work together and adapt the techniques of one medium to the needs of another.

But – and this was an uncomfortable thought – would we have been doing this if Rupert Murdoch hadn’t battered down the walls of trade union demarcation at Wapping?

Luckily I found an answer while reviving an old Palm m500 that had fallen out of favour. In the Wordsmith app I had written some extracts from the Penguin edition (1967) of The Communist Manifesto by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. On page 222 they wrote:

“The bourgeoisie cannot exist without constantly revolutionizing the instruments of production, and thereby the relations of production, and with them the whole relations of society.”

In other words, if it hadn’t been Rupert, it was a historical inevitability that it would have been someone else.

Somehow, that made me feel better.

Labels: , , ,

Friday, December 02, 2011

Whole lotta Economist

Hey Hey What Can I DoImage via WikipediaLeafing through last week's Economist (you know how it is, always too much to read in seven days) I settled into a very interesting feature about the economic advantages of diasporic communities (Weaving the world together, p 76, 19/11/11) – only to find myself somewhat distracted by the cross heads.

Whoever subbed it had used:

The immigrant song
In through the out door
Bringing it all back home
Going to California
Ramble on

Need a clue? Two words – Led Zeppelin

Whoever you are, thanks for a case study I can use in the second edition of Subediting For Journalists.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Labels: , , , , ,

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

More blogs about MagBlog.

View blog reactions